📌 Understanding the Difference: Fifth Metatarsal Apophysis vs. Fracture

https://youtube.com/shorts/3PTgaZCGquo

 

---

https://open.spotify.com/episode/7wJqd534Vmqx8y6KBSkxwB?si=4hz_MM9ESk2H2WMWN593lQ

[Lecture] 📌 Understanding the Difference: Fifth Metatarsal Apophysis vs. Fracture

https://youtu.be/uFPLAAqX6wc

 

 

1. Why This Distinction Matters

Fifth metatarsal apophysis is a normal secondary ossification center seen in children and adolescents, whereas a fracture represents a pathological break that follows trauma and often requires treatment.
Key differentiators include age, orientation on imaging, clinical context, and soft-tissue findings.

---

2. Age and Clinical Context

Apophysis

• Occurs in skeletally immature patients (girls ~9–11, boys ~11–14).
  
  
• Normal developmental variant with no definite trauma.
  
  
• May present as overuse pain (Iselin disease).
  
  

Fracture

• Occurs at any age, especially athletes.
  
  
• Typically follows acute inversion injury with sudden pain, swelling, or ecchymosis.
  
  

---

3. Radiographic Appearance

Apophysis

• Longitudinal/oblique radiolucent line.
  
  
• Parallel to the 5th metatarsal shaft.
  
  
• Does not extend into the cubometatarsal joint.
  
  
• Smooth margins reflecting orderly ossification.
  
  

Fracture

• Transverse or oblique line, orthogonal to shaft.
  
  
• Sharp, irregular edges.
  
  
• May extend into the articular surface (avulsion) or the metaphyseal–diaphyseal junction (Jones/stress fracture).
  
  

---

4. Symptoms and Physical Findings

Apophysis / Apophysitis

• Activity-related lateral foot pain.
  
  
• Point tenderness but minimal swelling and no ecchymosis.
  
  
• Radiographs may be normal or show mild irregularity.
  
  

Fracture

• Marked tenderness and visible swelling.
  
  
• Frequently includes ecchymosis.
  
  
• Pain causes difficulty with weight-bearing.
  
  

---

5. Course and Management

Apophysis (Normal Variant)

• No treatment required.
  
  
• Symptomatic Iselin disease responds to rest, activity modification, and NSAIDs.
  
  
• Apophysis fuses over 2–4 years.
  
  

Fracture

• Requires immobilization (boot or cast).
  
  
• Jones and diaphyseal stress fractures may require surgery due to nonunion risk.
  
  
• Correct classification is essential for prognosis.
  
  

---

6. Quick Comparison Table

Feature	Apophysis (Normal/Apophysitis)	Fracture
Typical Age	9–14 years	Any age
Trauma History	None or overuse	Clear acute trauma
Orientation	Parallel to shaft	Transverse/oblique
Joint Involvement	None	Possible
Soft-tissue Signs	Minimal swelling	Swelling, ecchymosis
Management	Observation / conservative	Immobilization ± surgery

 

#5thmetatarsal, #apophysis, #IselinDisease, #footfracture, #radiologyeducation, #MSKradiology, #pediatricsportsmedicine, #fracturevsapophysis, #orthopedics, #musculoskeletalimaging, #Vibecase,

---

Visualizing MSK Radiology: A Practical Guide to Radiology Mastery
© 2022 MSK MRI Jee Eun Lee All Rights Reserved.
No unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, or use for AI training.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/2Zjh65CWfTgzsQaERYCCKl?si=5bFqkYOuSgytg1P8uFjlKw

📌 5th Metatarsal Base Fractures: Classification, Diagnosis, and Management